Monday, July 16, 2018

Awww: Chevron Shakedown lawyer in search for new career


Ed.  I like to post the really ‘good news’ pieces whenever they appear on the web. Author Ed Morrissey of Hot Air provides a beauty.


The following article appeared in Hot Air on July 14th

Ed Morrissey

It didn’t get the headlines that Brett Kavanaugh and Donald Trump got this week. Heck, it didn’t even get the headlines that Steve Donziger used to get earlier in his career, after the attorney scored a $8.6 billion judgment against Chevron in Ecuador. On Tuesday, though, the state of New York yanked Donziger’s law license as a direct result of the fraudulent operation that produced the judgment:
Steven Donziger

An attorney who won an $8.6 billion award in an Ecuadoran court against Chevron Corp. over pollution of the Amazon rain forest later found to be obtained by coercion, fraud and bribery has lost his law license.

Steven Donziger is suspended from practicing law in New York state until further notice based on findings made in March 2014 by a federal trial court, a New York appeals court said July 10.

The 2014 findings of U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan are “uncontroverted evidence of serious professional misconduct which immediately threatens the public interest,” the appeals court said.

The only surprise was that it took four years for the state to act since Kaplan’s ruling. It’s been a year since the Supreme Court allowed a 2016 2nd Circuit appellate ruling stand that barred the enforcement of the award, thanks to the “deceit” involved. The appellate court ruling extensively recapped the findings of corruption involved in Donziger’s operation and remains perhaps the best summary of the case. A few of the section titles will give the flavor of Donziger’s well-established pattern of deceit and manipulation:

  • Donziger Attempts To Intimidate Chevron Into Settling by Trumpeting a Huge
    Remediation Cost Estimate Based Only on “SWAG”
  • Donziger Knowingly Submits to the Court Reports that Falsify a LAPs’ Expert’s
    7 Conclusions
  • Donziger and the LAPs Plan the Cabrera Report and Begin To Pay Him Secretly
  • Donziger Has Stratus Fabricate Objections To Be Submitted By the LAPs to the
    2 Cabrera Report that Stratus Wrote For the LAPs
The district court ruled that Donziger’s operation “constituted a RICO enterprise,” and that Donziger himself had conducted it “in a pattern of racketeering activity. … If ever there were a case warranting equitable relief with respect to a judgment procured by fraud, this is it.” The appellate court ruling agreed:

The record in the present case reveals a parade of corrupt actions by the LAPs’ legal team, including coercion, fraud, and bribery, culminating in the promise to Judge Zambrano of $500,000 from a judgment in favor of the LAPs. The Appeal Division’s Opinion provides no basis for an inference that the Lago Agrio Judgment was not the result of those corrupt acts, given its description of Judge Zambrano as having reached his decision without “assess[ing]” discrete “facts,” without following “concrete, express legal rule[s],” and without “consider[ing]” the “economic opinions or parameters that appear from the trial.” And given that the Appeal Division in its opinion (a) sets out no findings or damages assessments or calculations of its own, (b) approves Judge Zambrano’s approach as “sound,” “appropriate,” and presenting “no[] . . . reasons to modify what was ordered in the lower court’s judgment,” and (c) “ratifie[s]” Judge Zambrano’s award “in all its parts,” we conclude that Chevron’s $8.646 billion judgment debt, as approved by the Appeal Division, is clearly traceable to the LAPs’ legal team’s corrupt conduct.

With all of that on the record, affirmed in a 2014 judgment, upheld by the appellate court in 2016, and allowed to stand by the Supreme Court last year, one has to wonder how Donziger’s license lasted as long as it did. In fact, one has to wonder how Donziger hasn’t yet been prosecuted for his actions in the Chevron Shakedown.


Bloomberg’s Joe Nocera still has some sympathy for Donziger, who claims he’s being railroaded by Chevron, but even that sympathy has its limits. Nocera concludes that Donziger has “no one to blame but himself”:

In an email he once wrote to me, Donziger complained that he was “the target of what is probably the most well-funded corporate retaliation campaign in U.S. history.” And you know what? He’s probably right. Chevron employed an army of lawyers from the pricey firm of Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher. It sent private investigators to Ecuador. It forced Donziger’s experts to retract their own report. And the law firm of Squire Patton Boggs actually apologized to Chevron, and paid it $15 million, for its role in defending Donziger.

But Donziger has no one to blame but himself. I don’t doubt that Donziger had honorable motives when he began the case. But as he realized that Chevron was not going to fold — and, perhaps, that his case was not as big or as airtight as he had originally thought — he lost his ethical compass. Chevron nailed him for it.

Although Donziger vows to press on, the suspension of his law license could well be the end of this saga. After 25 years, the only moral of this story is that whether or not corporations are evil, if you are going to take them on, you’d better have the goods. And you’d better play by the rules.

Nocera’s being too kind. After reading through the breadth and depth of Donziger’s racketeering in the ruling, the obvious conclusion was that Chevron was actually blameless, as Donziger had to manufacture practically everything in his case and bribe the judges and experts to pull off the scam. Whether or not “corporations are evil,” one thing’s for sure — this was an evil scheme intended to enrich Donziger. His biggest mistake, other than being corrupt, was to attempt to pull his scam on people who had the resources to beat him — and beat him by following the rules.

The Wall Street Journal’s editorial board hits closer to the mark:

Plaintiff attorney Steven Donziger’s attempted looting of Chevron for spurious environmental crimes in Ecuador ranks among the biggest legal scams in history. The law finally caught up to Mr. Donziger this week as a New York court pulled his legal license. …

Luckily U.S. judges aren’t as corruptible. A Second Circuit Court of Appeals panel unanimously upheld Judge Kaplan’s ruling in 2016, but the shameless Mr. Donziger has continued to importune other countries where Chevron has assets to enforce the fraudulent Ecuadorian judgment. An appeals court in Argentina and Brazil’s Superior Court of Justice recently rejected Mr. Donziger’s petitions.

On Tuesday New York’s first Appellate Division took a step toward reining in Mr. Donziger’s marauding by suspending his license to practice. “Judge Kaplan’s findings constitute uncontroverted evidence of serious professional misconduct which immediately threatens the public interest,” the court declared.

Mr. Donziger’s foot soldiers in other countries continue to try to enforce the judgment, but credit to the New York court for sending a strong message to conniving trial lawyers that their shenanigans won’t be tolerated in American courtrooms.

That action, while commendable, seems awfully late in coming … and a somewhat mild punishment for someone who created a RICO organization that aimed at taking $8.6 billion to which it was not entitled.

Addendum: Maybe it’s time for Phelim McAleer to stage his verbatim play on the Chevron Shakedown, The $18 Billion Prize, on Broadway. Perhaps it might even get an actor or two who’ll want the meaty role at the center of the racket. (Note: The original Ecuadorian judgment was close to $18 billion in damages and punitive awards; a later court threw out the punitive awards.)

No comments:

Post a Comment