|Pa. Supreme Court|
Sunday, March 25, 2018
Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justices Face Impeachment
The following article appeared in Wizbang on March 23rd
From The Hill:
A Pennsylvania state representative has introduced resolutions to impeach four of the five state Supreme Court justices who voted to override congressional district maps they said were unfairly gerrymandered on partisan lines.
The resolutions, introduced by state Rep. Cris Dush (R), accuse Justices Kevin Dougherty, Christine Donohue, Debra McClosky Todd and David Wecht of misbehavior in office.
In a memo to fellow House members,
Dush said the ruling overriding Pennsylvania’s U.S. House district lines
amounted to an overstep of judicial authority under the state Constitution,
which lays out the path by which a bill becomes a law — in this case, a bill to
delineate the district lines after the decennial Census and reapportionment
“The five Justices who signed this order that blatantly and clearly contradicts the plain language of the Pennsylvania Constitution engaged in misbehavior in office,” Dush wrote to fellow members.
In an interview Tuesday, Dush said he had drafted the resolutions shortly after the Supreme Court’s initial order in January. He had hoped to add language from the U.S. Supreme Court, if they took up the case. The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday denied Pennsylvania Republicans’ request to hear a challenge to the state Supreme Court decision.
“This is basically 7th grade civics class all over again, the separation of powers and the authority of the legislature,” Dush told The Hill. “The courts basically are there to interpret when there’s conflict in the law, and they don’t have any sovereignty.”
The Supreme Court’s January order struck down the existing congressional district maps, under which Republicans won 13 of 18 seats in the 2016 elections. The court gave legislative Republicans just a few weeks to draw new maps, before they imposed district lines drawn by their own special master.
“The maps are indeed a piece of legislation. We write it out and we break it out by counties, cities, townships, and even down to the very voting precincts and wards if necessary,” Dush added. “The product the state Supreme Court produced is just a series of maps.”
This is as raw a power grab by justices as has been seen for some time. The Pennsylvania constitution clearly grants the legislature the power to draw congressional district lines. Democrats currently hold a 5-2 majority on the supreme court (justices are elected) and are doing what they can to sidestep the law in order to redraw federal lines in a Democrat-friendly fashion.
While citizens have had to endure some pretty awful court decisions on a local and federal level, this kind of power grab is breathtaking. The GOP, which controls both houses of the Pennsylvania Assembly (majorities of 59% in the House and 68% in the Senate), have the votes to oust the monarchs in black robes.
Judges have been crossing the line for a long time. It’s high time the People reasserted their constitutional prerogatives.